The Fallacy Detective
Video Articles News Blogs Books & DVD Contact Home

How I Became a Vegetarian

2008-07-25 by Hans Bluedorn in , 311 views

What do you think of this person’s reasons for becoming a vegetarian?

Is she saying everyone shouldn’t eat meat, or is she just talking about a personal choice?


Comments

1 • Cori Long • July 29, 2008 • 8:38 PM

Personal Choice. Doesn’t do much to convince us to avoid meat.

2 • James • July 31, 2008 • 11:35 PM

Her final statement “while everyone else is eating meat” begs of guilt by association no?

3 • beforHim • August 12, 2008 • 5:13 PM

I thought a personal choice, until she said, “I feel really good doing my part”.  I’d say it’s a hidden agenda disguised as a personal choice (the choice she made was still personal none-the-less).

What fallacy would this be?  Disguising a hidden agenda within a story?

4 • ben • September 05, 2008 • 11:56 AM

God put animals on the earth so we could eat them.

5 • Jeremiah • October 20, 2008 • 5:45 PM

She looks funny in that tie.